Journal of Human Anatomy & Physiology
Download PDF
Research Article
Utilization of Prostate Serum Antigen (PSA) Screening Services among the Igala People of North Central Nigeria
Akwu PB1, Shaibu GO2* and Omotoso OD1
1Department of Human Anatomy, Kogi State University, Anyigba
2Department of Sociology, Kogi State University, Anyigba
*Address for Correspondence: Shaibu GO, Gabriel Ocholi, Department of Sociology, Kogi State University, Anyigba; E-mail: gshaibu81@yahoo.com
Submission: 30 June, 2019
Accepted: 16 September, 2019
Published: 18 September, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 Akwu PB, et al. This is an open access article
distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original work is properly cited.
Abstract
Prostate cancer according to the world Health Organization
is one of the silent killers of the African men. It is associated with
avalanche health burden in physical, social and economic
dimensions. Consequently, early detection has been identified as the
most effective intervention and management of this social malady.
This study is a descriptive survey which utilized secondary data to
investigate the influence of socio-demographic characteristics on the
utilization of the prostate screening services among the Igala people
of North Central Nigeria at the Kogi State University Teaching Hospital,
Anyigba. The substantive issues of this study were the level of utilization
of the PSA services, the influence of socio-demographic characteristics
on utilization, motivation for PSA screening as well as the standardized
PSA levels of patients. The study utilized secondary data obtained
from Kogi State University Teaching Hospital. Study data was collected
from the information unit of the hospital following informed consent
of the hospital management. The data was analysed using multiple
regression analysis through the application of SPSS. 20.0. Findings of
the study reveals that the level of utilization of the PSA services among
the vulnerable population in the study area is low, motivation for
screening is by clinical referrals while PSA levels is generally high. The
hypotheses tested revealed that socio-demographic characteristics
of the respondents are related to utilization with (p=0.00), patients’
PSA levels is also socio-demographically determined as (p=0.12).
Recommendations from these findings includes: tailored information,
health education and the use of reward system by government and
non-governmental organizations.
Background of the Study
Prostate Cancer (PC), an adenocarcinoma of the male prostate
gland, is progressively becoming a significant health burden among
men in the world. However, available literature reveals that PC
treatment is possible if there is an early diagnosis, at the time the
disease is still localised in the prostrate [1,2]. Early detection of the
disease is therefore a fundamental component of a successful prostate
cancer therapy and one of the common measures adopted is the
PSA test. The Prostate Serum Antigen (PSA) test measures the level
of PSA in a man’s blood. The rationale for screening is to reduce
the possibility of developing the disease at the asymptomatic stage.
According to the World Health Organisation (2009) [3], this method
was adapted from the success recorded in the Breast Examination
(BSE) mammography and Pap-smear tests conducted in breast and
cervical cancer interventions respectively.
It has been found that PC is the leading cancer in terms of incidence
and mortality in men from Africa and the Caribbean (IARC 2014)
[4]. The study also notes that PC is a growing problem in Africa with
approximately 28,006 deaths from PC in 2010, and approximately
57,048 deaths projected in 2030 if aggressive interventions are not
put in place. Prostate cancer is rarely seen among males below the age of 40, the most common cancer among men in Nigeria and Patients
usually present with locally advanced disease or metastatic disease at
diagnosis with tendency for high Gleason scores. The PC in Nigeria
may be as great as that noted in black men in the United States,
which may suggest a common enhancing genetic predisposition [5].
Treatment modalities for prostate cancer are proving difficult, and
the prognosis of untreated or inadequately managed cases is often
usually poor especially in developing countries [6]. This could be
attributed to the high cost of medication and surgical interventions
required to treat patients with a diagnosed condition [6].
World Health Organization (2009) observes that thirty percent of
cancers are curable if detected early while thirty percent of cancers are
treatable with prolonged survival if detected early and thirty percent
of cancer patients can be provided with symptom management and
palliative care. Like many other health problems ravaging developing
countries in Nigeria, early detection of prostate cancer has been
problematic due to a host of factors which are primarily socioeconomic in nature. Yet, at present, there are no clear strategies
towards preventing prostate cancer through life-style modification
or preventive intervention and therefore, understanding factors that
determine uptake of PC will be highly beneficial as a precautionary
measure against the onset of the disease.
Odunayo and Ogundele (2015) have shown that Prostate cancer
screening is not a common practice in Nigeria in spite of its place
as the most commonly diagnosed cancer in Nigerian men as well
as primary intervention [7]. The practical implication of this is that
majority of patients usually present in the hospital with the disease
at the advanced stage. Although men with advanced stage disease
may benefit from palliative treatment, their tumours are generally
not curable. Thus, a screening program that could accurately
identify asymptomatic men with aggressive localized tumours
might be expected to substantially reduce prostate cancer morbidity,
including urinary obstruction, painful metastases and mortality [8].
In developed countries, screening for PSA has led to early detection
and management of the disease. However, in developing countries
particularly in Africa, routine screening has remained low due to a host of social, cultural and political factors leading to reduced
detection rates, poor management and increased mortality from the
disease. Argue that low education has a relationship with prostatic
diseases among Blacks in the United States of America [9].
Statement of the Research Problem
GLOBOCAN Cancer Facts Sheets, 2012 (GCFS, 2012) opines that
all men are at risk of developing prostate cancer and about one man
in six will be diagnosed with prostate cancer during his lifetime [10].
The burden of prostate cancer in Nigeria is so significant that GCFS
(2012) reports indicate that in 2012 there was 307,000 prostate cancer
implicates prostate cancer as the fifth leading cause of death from
cancer in men (6.6% of the total men deaths) and that the mortality
rates are generally high in predominantly black populations. Prostate
cancer is a major health problem and the most common cancer in
men and the most commonly diagnosed cancer among Nigerian men
however; CaP screening is not a common practice in Nigeria Oliver
(2008). In Nigeria, Prostate cancer is the most common cancer among
men. It is also associated with a high mortality rate (71/100,000).
Ogundele and Ikwuerowo (2015) attribute the high rate of cancer
mortality to advanced prostate cancer presentation by African
men [7], emphasizing the need for prevention, earlier detection,
and improvements in management of this disease. Odunayo and
Ogundele, 2015 have shown that Prostate cancer screening is not
a common practice in Nigeria in spite of prostate cancer being the
most commonly diagnosed cancer in Nigerian men [7]. Lending
credence, many prostate cancer cases therefore present late with
symptoms of local invasion or distant metastasis [11]. The primary
goal of prostate cancer screening is to reduce avoidable morbidity
and mortality through early detection towards achieving prompt
management. Though, many studies on the need for prostate cancer
screening has been reported in Nigeria, such results and specifically
that on demographic characteristics on the study area is non-existent.
This present study is anchored on demographic characteristics and
utilization of PSA services at the Kogi State University Teaching
Hospital, Anyigba.
Research Objectives
To determine the level of utilization of PSA services among the
vulnerable population among the Igala people of Kogi East Senatorial
District.
To determine the clients’ motivation for the utilization of PSA
services.
Research Hypotheses
1. Socio-demographic characteristics have no influence on
utilization of PSA services among patients.
2. Socio-demographic characteristics have no influence on the
PSA levels of patients who accessed PSA service at KSUTH.
Materials and Methods
Research design: This study is a descriptive and diagnostic research which aims at
linking resource socio- demographic characteristics with utilization
of Prostate cancer screening services at the Kogi State University Teaching Hospital, located in Anyigba, Kogi State, Nigeria.
Study area: The study was conducted in Kogi East Senatorial District of Kogi
state, Nigeria.
Kogi State is situated in the savannah region between longitude
05 °
20”-08 °
00” East and latitude 05 °
30”-08 °
50” North with the State
capital at Lokoja, located at the confluence of the two major Rivers in
Nigeria, River Niger and River Benuie [12]. The state is bordered to
the East by Benue State and to the South by Edo, Enugu and Ondo
States and to the North by Niger and Nasarawa States and to the West
by Kwara and Ekiti States. The state is made up of twenty-one Local
Government Areas (LGAs). The Eastern Flank of the State has 9 local
Government Areas dominated by the Igala people who are said to
be the 9th populous ethnic group in Nigeria. The place is precisely
located between longitude 06 °
30”-07 °
00” East and latitude 06 °
30”-
08 °
00” North. There are two main seasons, dry and wet seasons. The
wet season begins in March and stops towards the end of October.
According to major economic activity in the area is agrarian in nature
and majority of the people lack job opportunities [13]. Kogi East
Senatorial District is the seat of Kogi State University, Anyigba where
the Teaching Hospital is also located.
Type of data and methods of analysis: This study relied on secondary data obtained from the Kogi
state University Teaching Hospital (KSUTH). The data obtained
from the information unit of the hospital following authorization
of the hospital authority was manually sorted, collated and analysed
using the Statistical Package for Social Science Analysis, (SPSS)
20.0. The demographic variables of the patients were presented
in tables using descriptive statistics of frequency distribution.
Table 1: Socio-demographic Characteristics of Patients Attending Kogi State
University Teaching Hospital, Anyigba.
Table 3: Motivation for PSA Screening among Patients Attending Kogi State
University Teaching Hospital, Anyigba.
Furthermore, the hypotheses posed by the study were analysed using
the linear regression analysis. The individual and sum of the sociodemographic characteristics of the respondents were analysed for
better understanding.
Data presentation and analysis: The data for this study was collected from the information unit
of the Kogi State University Teaching Hospital, Anyigba. It includes
the Socio-demographic characteristics, motivation for PSA screening
and level of PSA among patients who utilized the PSA screening
services located at the University Teaching Hospital within a period
of five years (2013-2018). The data were analysed in both descriptive
and inferential statistics and presented in tabular form (Table 1).
KSUTH health information unit, 2019: The table above reveals that the total number of patients who
utilized the PSA services is low compared to the general population
of the vulnerable people and the period of the study. The sociodemographic characteristics of the respondents reveal that patients
who are between the age range of 70 years and above are the majority
with a percentage point of 39.7. This is followed by patients who are
between the age range of percent of the respondents are between the
age range of 59-60 with the percentage point of 21.3. Furthermore,
patients between the age range of 50-59 attracts 20.7 percentage
point followed in decreasing order by patients between the age range
of 40-49 years who scored 10.3 percentage points. On education, a
significant number of the respondents representing 77.6 percent have
no formal education. Patients with secondary education accounted
for 8.5 percent of the patients while Primary or Tertiary education
accounts for 6.9 percent, respectively.
In addition, data on the occupation of patients reveals that
farming is the domineering occupation with 39 followed by trading
with occupies 27 percent. Civil servant had 19 percent score and
Artisans occupy 15 percent score respectively.
Finally, data on the religious affiliation of patients show that 37.9
percent of them are adherents of Islamic religion, 32.8 are Christians
while 29.3 are adherents of African Traditional Religion (ATR)
(Table 2).
Data in Table 3 above representing the prostate antigen level of
patients screened at the University Teaching Hospital reveals that
75.9 percent of the patients investigated had PSA level of 10 and above, 13.8 percent of them had a level of 0-4 while 10.3 percent of
them had a level of 5-9 (Table 3).
Data in Table 4 above representing patients’ motivation for
Prostate Antigen Screening revealed that a substantial percentage of
the patients who utilized the PSA services were screened on clinical
request while only 5.2 percent of them utilized the service on routine
request.
Presentation and analysis of research hypotheses: Two hypotheses were tested to investigate the relationship
between patients’ demographic characteristics and the utilization of
PSA screening services. The hypotheses were tested using multiple
regression analysis. The table above shows the influence of sociodemographic characteristics on the utilization of PSA services
among the vulnerable population of the Igala people of North
Central Nigeria. The result of the multiple regression analysis
reveals that motivation for utilization of PSA services among the
study population is influenced by demographic characteristics. The
sum of demographic factors shows that p =.000<0.05. Similarly, the
individual contribution of the demographic factors: age =.048<0.05,
education.000< 0.05, occupation.001<0.05 except religion.622>0.05.
Although religion is not a significant factor, the sum influence of the
demographic characteristics on the utilization of PSA services means
that that the hypothesis is rejected (Table 4).
The table above shows the influence of socio-demographic
characteristics on the PSA level of patients who utilized the PSA
services at the university Teaching Hospital The result of the multiple
regression analysis reveals that PSA level ( 0-4, 5-10 and greater
than 10) is determined by socio-demographic characteristics of the
respondents. The result of the analysis revealed that the p value of
the sum of the demographic factors age, education, religion and
occupation is significant (p=.012<0.05). However, the contribution
of individual demographic factors age, (p=.992) education, (p=.691)
religion, (p=.002) and occupation, (p=.004) showed mixed PSA levels.
On the strength of this finding, the hypothesis is rejected (Table 5).
Discussion of Findings
This study was aimed at establishing an empirical link between
the socio-demographic characteristics of patients and the utilization
of PSA services in terms of motivation for utilization as well as the
PSA levels of patients. Consequently, the age range of patients, level
of education, occupation and religion were the socio-demographic
variables utilised in this study. The socio- demographic feature of age
reveals that patients between the age range of 70 and above occupied
the highest category of people who utilized the service. The finding
showed a decreasing age range with decreasing trend of the utilization
of the screening services. This is consistent with the finding of who
correlated increasing age with the incidence of prostate cancer [14].
In a related dimension, data on education reveals that majority of the
patients representing 77.6 percent have no formal education.
The result of the hypothesis which investigated the influence
of demographic characteristics on utilization of PSA services was
rejected. This shows that age, 0.04 education 0.00 and occupation 0.02
except religion with r =.006 > than 0.05 predicts utilization of PSA
services in the study area. This finding is consistent with the finding.
Table 4: Multiple regression analysis showing the influence of demographic characteristic on utilization of PSA services.
Table 5: Multiple regression analysis showing the influence of demographic characteristic on the PSA level of patients who utilized.
of who argued that low socio-economic status are significantly related
to prostatic diseases among Blacks in the United States of America
[9]. This is also true of farming and trading in the study area that
correlates more with poor socio economic status. Even the civil
servants who participated in the study may be at the bottom cadre
of the civil service. This is because, majority of the patients are either
uneducated or only have basic or secondary education which can in
most cases offer menial and unprofessional jobs in the civil service.
In a related development, findings about the PSA levels indicate
that significant percentage of the participants representing 75
percent have PSA levels of 10 and above. This level is not only high
but suggestive of serious prostatic diseases that requires further
clinical enquiry. It is also suggestive of the fact that patients have
failed to utilize the screening services in the past there by leading to
heightened levels that are correlated with serious morbidity, disability
and mortality. The result of the hypothesis which also linked
demographic characteristics with PSA levels was rejected. Hence, age
range, education and occupation of the respondents influence PSA
levels in the study area. This is in line with who argue that relationship
exists between prostatic diseases and socio-economic characteristics
of the respondents [9]. This finding also supports who reveal that
although, prostate cancer is a growing problem in Nigeria [7], and
early screening is not a common practice.
Finally, finding on screening motivation reveal that more than 94
percent of the patients participated on clinical request. This suggests
that it was not on their personal volition to utilize the service. This
confirms the report of poor utilization of prostate screening services
among vulnerable men in Africa. The implication of this is that a
significant proportion of PSA screening utilization in the study area
is dependent on clinical suspicion which underscores the essence of
the services. This finding also coincides with who argue that early
screening is not a common practice and the implication according to
[7,15]. Is that many prostate cancer cases therefore present late with
symptoms of local invasion or distant metastasis [16].
Conclusion and Recommendations
This paper is a descriptive and diagnostic study which
uses secondary data to establish a link between demographic
characteristics and the utilization of prostate cancer services at the Kogi State University Teaching Hospital, Anyigba. The result of the
test showed that in the period of five years under study, only few
(58) percent and insignificant number of the vulnerable population
utilized the services. In addition to this, more than 94 percent of those
who utilized the services did so on clinical recommendations.
But more worrisome is the high PSA levels of greater number of those
participants.
On the strength of these findings, the study recommends that: The mass media should create awareness on the rising incidence
of prostate cancer as well as those vulnerable to the disease.
Community education approach should be adopted by the FMOH
and non- governmental organizations using occupational groups on
the benefits of early screening and detection on effective management
of prostate cancer. The Federal Ministry of Health should introduce
a reward system mechanism into prostate cancer screening
programmes to make it attractive to the vulnerable population.