Journal of Forensic Investigation
Research Article
The Impact of Culture and Belief in So-Called Honour Killings A Comparative Study between Honour Murders and other Perpetrators of Violence in Germany
Kizilhan JI1,2*
1Institute for Psychotherapy and Psychotraumtology, University of
Duhok, Iraq
2Institute of Transcultural Health Science, State University Baden-
Württemberg, Germany
*Address for Correspondence: Dr. Kizilhan JI, State University Baden-Württemberg Schramberger
Str. 26, D-78054 Villingen-Schwenningen,Germany, Tel:4977203906-
217;Fax: 497720 3906-219; Email: kizilhan@dhbwvs.de
Submission: 19 August, 2019;
Accepted: 28 August, 2019;
Published: 03 September, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 Kizilhan JI, et al. This is an open access article
distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original work is properly cited.
Abstract
Although the experts assume that, in addition to general
psychosocial stress, culture-specific and migration-related factors
play a part in the criminal tendencies of migrants, there has not
been much research done to date on the special situation of those
persons committing honour killings. This study starts from the premise
that these perpetrators have a patriarchal-religious mind-set and
have developed a conception of “honour”. In connection with
biographical stresses they are more willing to injure or kill other people
if the values and standards they believe in are not respected. We
interviewed 41 men with a Turkish background between 18and 35in
Germany who had killed other persons who they thought had violated
their concept of honour and who then had been convicted of murder
or manslaughter (“honour killers”). The two control groups comprised
44 criminals with an ethnic Turkish background who were in prison on
charges of using violence without causing death and 40 prisoners who
had been convicted of murder or manslaughter for other reasons.
To ascertain the respective motives for their actions, we used semistandardised
interviews in jails. Compared to the control groups, the
group of honour killers revealed significant differences as regards
ethnicity and socialisation, structural violence in their country of origin
and stresses within the family. We found a correlation between the
parameters “reinforcement through the social milieu” and “costbenefit
considerations”, “ancestry and socialisation” and “structural
violence”. In the case of the honour killers we found strong patriarchalreligious
cognitions with structural violence which triggered actionoriented
and target-oriented aggression when the person concerned
felt that the standards and values which he believed in, had been
infringed.