Journal of Environmental Studies
Download PDF
Review Article
The Overpopulation: Selected Environmental and Geographic Aspects
Jargin SV*
Department of Pathology, People’s Friendship University of Russia, Russian Federation USSR
*Address for Correspondence:Jargin SV, Department of Pathology, People’s Friendship
University of Russia, Russian Federation USSR. E-mail Id: sjargin@mail.ru
Submission: 17 April, 2024
Accepted: 04 June, 2024
Published: 08 June, 2024
Copyright: © 2024 Jargin SV. This is an open access article
distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction
in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Keywords:Demography; Population; Migrations; Environment; Nuclear Energy
Abstract
Ecological damage is generally proportional to the population
density. The demographic growth contributes to shortages of fresh
water and food. Many countries experience water scarcity while
agricultural production increases through overexploitation of water
resources, deforestation and other environmental damage. Potential
solutions would require adoption of new principles, in particular, that
no population group on a national or international scale, neither ethnic
nor confessional minorities, may obtain advantages because of a faster
growth. Relevant demographic problems of the North Caucasus and
the eastern Mediterranean are discussed here. Both the mountainous
and arid territories are hardly suitable for self-sustaining existence of the
dense population. Both regions receive financial support and, at the
same time, are sources of emigration. The agriculture in conditions of
insufficient water and energy supply is economically and ecologically
unfavorable as fossil fuels are used for the water desalination, which is
accompanied by greenhouse gas emissions. The energy for desalination
could be supplied by nuclear power plants. The weightiest argument
against nuclear facilities is that they are potential war targets.Durable
peace and international cooperation are needed for this and other
humanitarian projects.
Introduction
Ecological damage is generally proportional to the population
density. The demographic growth contributes to the shortage of
fresh water and food [1,2]. Many countries encounter water scarcity
while agricultural production increases through overexploitation
and pollution of water resources, deforestation, desertification, soil
erosion etc. The humankind is in a demographic deadlock [3] but
no realistic solutions have been proposed. Such solutions would
require a revision of certain ethical clichés and propagation of new
principles, in particular, that no population group on a national or
international scale, neither ethnic nor confessional minorities, may
obtain advantages because of a faster growth, even if it would disagree
with numerical democracy. In view of the global overpopulation,
those who have had many children must logically live in more
crowded conditions. Acceptance of this principle could build a basis
for international understanding and trust. Without procreative
competition, different peoples would more likely live in peace. In
the last quarter of the 20th century, the population grew faster in
less industrialized countries than in more developed ones; while the
increment in greenhouse gas emissions has been much higher in
Asia and Africa than in America and Europe [4]. The forthcoming
industrialization of the regions formerly regarded as developing is
significant due to less efficient environment conservation measures
and vast dimensions of the process, proportional to the population
size. In the past, overpopulation has been reduced by homicide,
epidemics and starvation. Today, there is a possibility to apply
humane, scientifically based methods, consciously choosing between
the birth rate restriction and mortality rise. Surgical sterilization is
the most reliable method of birth control; it was applied in India in
the 1970s, but later these measures have been rolled back. India is
the most populous country in the world today. China had the largest
population for many decades with a fertility rate as high as 6.0 before
1970, decreased to 1.5-1.7 by the late 1990s. In an attempt to elevate
birth rates, the one child policy was replaced by two child policy from
2015. However, the total fertility rate continued to fall, reaching 1.3
by 2020. Additional pronatalist measures have been introduced in
2021 [5].
Countries receiving immigrants decide whom they admit and
whom not. Sterilization can be taken into account making decisions
about residence and work permits. The male sterilization (vasectomy)
is a simple and harmless procedure. The female sterilization (tubal
ligation) can be performed without additional trauma at a birth by
cesarean section. A more frequent use of cesarean tubal ligation
would be especially favorable for overpopulated regions with a
gender imbalance [6]. Certainly, surgical sterilization can be seen as
a violation of the bodily integrity. The same, however, can be said
about sexual and reproductive coercion committed for migration/
accommodation purposes or to spread a certain genotype, with
conscious or subconscious geopolitical motives (discussed below).
Overpopulation and ethnic transformations:
Logically, rapidly growing peoples should live in less spacious
conditions. Consequences of the gender imbalance must be borne
by populations with a male predominance due to immigration and/
or sex-selective abortions. The recognition of these principles should
become a basis for the international understanding and trust. In
consideration of ecological and economic conditions, an optimal
fertility level must be recommended for different regions. Who
would determine the level? Primarily, everyone for her- or himself.
In a country with sufficient food and water resources, the birth rate of
the titular nation can be higher than in the regions where people are
consuming desalinated water and foodstuff acquired for the foreign
aid or oil revenues. An international authority could issue evidencebased
recommendations.In the former Soviet Union (SU), the fertility rate varies from
3.8 in Tajikistan to 1.2 in Ukraine and 1.5 in Russian Federarion
(RF), which includes the Caucasus and other ethnic homelands with
high fertility [7]. Within RF, maximal population increase has been
observed in Ingushetia, Chechnya, Tuva and Dagestan; while the
population is decreasing most rapidly in Tver, Tula, Pskov, Leningrad
and Novgorod provinces [8]. The emigration of ethnic Russians
from the Caucasus and Central Asia started several decades ago and
increased after the dissolution of SU. At the same time, indigenous
people from these regions come massively to Russia. Migration
distances reach from the Caucasus and Middle Asia to Moscow, St.
Petersburg, Siberia and the Far East [9]. The highest emigration rate
was registered in North Ossetia-Alania [10]. Armenian minority
is increasing on the Caucasian Riviera, where they have massively
participated in privatization and construction of houses, changing
the panorama of the Black Sea coast [11,12]. In Stavropol, Krasnodar
and Rostov provinces, percentages of Chechens and other indigenous
Caucasians are growing [8,13,14]. Among motives of the emigration
has been the shortage of land, overcrowding, economic factors and
lack of security [14]. At the same time, the Chechen Republic receives
considerable federal funding. The region received assistance from the
UN World Food Programme in the first decade of the 21st century.
The North Caucasus takes a lot from the Russian federal budget
giving not much back [Table 1]. In addition, federal funds have been
purloined on a large scale [15].
[16]. For prevention of conflicts, minorities should not grow
faster than the titularethnic group of a country. This is understood
in many Jewish families. However, in the orthodoxmilieu the birth
rate remains relatively high. In some cities, New York in the first
place, the Jewish population is considerable. After the World War II,
people of Jewish descent had a possibility to lead a normal life almost
everywhere. Migration to the populated territory of Palestine with
a shortage of water and energy resources occurred after individual
decisions of the migrants, who were going, directly or indirectly, to
take possession of other people’s land and housing. Arguments like
“historical patrimony” or the dream of reassembling [17] are not
necessarily acceptable for other peoples. Moreover, both sides of
the Middle Eastern conflict have applied terrorism [18]. The state
violence is generally more destructive than that carried out by nonstate
actors [19].
Back in the 1860s, the number of Jews in Palestine was
approximately 14,000 or 4% of the total population of 350,000 [18].
From 1948 to 2002 the population of Israel increased from 806,000
to 6.3 million (including occupied territories – 9.8 million) [20].
Combined with immigration, the population of the arid territory
Table 1:The part of the own income in the regional budget (%). The rest is the
federal dotation (2020)
largely dependent on the foreign help and water desalination, heads
to 16 million by mid-century [21]. Despite popular beliefs, the
fertility rate of Israeli and Palestinian women is approximately equal
(3.1): higher than in Iran (1.8), Tunisia (2.0), Saudi Arabia (2.1) and
some neighboring countries, being the highest in developed parts of
the world [21]. Even friends of Israel cannot answer the question, why
Palestinian Christians and Muslims should cede the land, immobile
property and water sources to immigrants from different continents,
including those who declared themselves Judaists just because it was
required for the “repatriation”. The law of return does not include
those who practice other religions. As for atheists, according to
witnesses, they must documentarily declare themselves Judaists. In
view of the Ukraine conflict, the double standards should be stressed:
no sanctions were imposed against Israel for comparable military
actions. On the contrary, financial and technical aid was provided.
Apparently, certain spheres on both sides of the Middle Eastern
conflict have acted for mutual benefit in receiving foreign aid: some
get it from the West, others from oil-producing countries. The Camp
David Accords was an efficient instrument of obtaining foreign aid.
Prior to the Ukraine war, Israel was the largest cumulative recipient
of the U.S. foreign help since the World War II [22,23]. After the
Accords, American aid to Egypt increased considerably. By 2003, over
a half of the economy of Palestinian Territories was dependent on the
foreign help [24]. Besides, Israel receives regular financial aid from
Germany. In this connection, ethnic discrimination in the German
immigration policy should be pointed out. Since 1990, it sufficed to
declare oneself a Jew to obtain an unlimited residence permit and
social assistance. In this way, other foreigners are discriminated: after
many years of work they have to leave the country. Some refugees
exist for social benefits for years (so-called welfare dependence of
immigrants). The welfare agency is regarded as a club for selected
public, where the wealth is distributed: regular payment of benefits,
medical and pension insurance, free education, apartments, etc.
Some refugees are engaged in business evading taxes. Despite legal
and moral barriers, many refugees of this kind travel to their native
countries in the former SU. There are cases when the refugees rented
out their Moscow apartments, or when a father operated business in
Russia, while the family lived in Germany for the welfare benefits [25].
A solution for Palestine and some adjacent territories could be
a protectorate by developed nations to ensure safety and to curb the
population growth, stimulated by the long-lasting conflict. After the
World War I, Palestine, Syria and Lebanon were governed by Great
Britain and France according to the League of Nations mandates. The
overpopulated territory is arid and has not much natural resources.
It appears questionable, whether the West Europeans would be
interested in getting deeply involved there. Then it is logically the
turn of Russians and Turks. The Russian Palestine is an idea with
rich traditions [26]. The Turks, for their part, have great experience
of administration in the region. The spheres of influence could be
reasonably divided.
The agriculture in conditions of insufficient water and energy
supply is economically and ecologically unfavorable as fossil fuels
are burnt for the water desalination. The water consumption
and pollution in Palestine exceeds natural replenishment
[27]. It is expected that the gap between the water supply and demand
will widen [24]. The energy for desalination could be supplied by
nuclear power plants (NPPs). Obviously, durable peace is needed
because NPPs are potential war targets. There are no alternatives
to nuclear energy [28]. In the long run, non-renewable fossil fuels
will become more expensive, contributing to the population growth
in oil producing regions and poverty elsewhere. NPPs have come
back to the agenda due to concerns about increasing global energy
demand and climate changes. Well-run NPPs pose less risk than fossil
fuel power stations [28-30]. Health burdens are greatest for power
stations based on coal and oil. The burdens are smaller for natural
gas and much lower for the NPPs. The same ranking applies also to
the greenhouse gas emissions and thus probably to climate changes
[30]. Hopefully, nuclear fission will be replaced in the future by
fusion, which is intrinsically safer. The fusion should offer a source of
safe, clean power generation with a plentiful supply of raw materials
[31,32]. Durable peace and international cooperation are needed for
this and other large-scale projects.
Migrations, heredity, reproductive coercion:
It is known that birthrate inequalities can eventually result in
geopolitical transformations. Here follow some details in addition to
the previously published [25,33]. The social progress is supposed to go
along with improvements of morals. However, migrations confound
this process. Temporary, fictive marriages and reproductive coercion
are used to spread certain genotypes and/or to cement marriages
arranged to obtain a residence permit and/or accommodation [34].
This is a probable cause of increased birthrates observed immediately
after the immigration [35]. Reproductive coercion can involve
physical, sexual, financial or psychological abuse [36]. Reportedly,
about 70% of sexual violence cases in Moscow are committed by
immigrants from Central Asia; some other ethnic groups are also
active in this field. About 75% of rapes in the Moscow province were
perpetrated by migrants [37]. The sexual violence may be conditioned
by ethnic, religious, economic or social conflicts [38].Violence against women can be perpetrated or condoned
by the state [39]. In 2017 Vladimir Putin has signed into law an
amendment that decriminalizes some forms of domestic violence.
Apropos, physical abuse was described in his biographies. It has
been hypothesized that Putin isre-enacting his own and his family’s
traumas in conditions of an intergenerational traumatic chain;
details and references are in [40]. Governmental policies aimed at
the fertility elevation tend to disregard reproductive rights of women.
Some church functionaries, endorsing the Ukraine war, engage in
moralizing, opposing to abortions, sex education and birth control,
depicting childbearing as a duty. Like in the Orient, the government
joins forces with religious figures in order to curtail women’s
rights, including their sexual and reproductive autonomy [41]. The
extremely popular TV series such as “Sled” (Trace) and “Slepaia”
(The Blind) regularly present unexpected pregnancies both in and
out of wedlock as natural and unavoidable while contraception is
hardly ever mentioned. The risks associated with contraceptives and
abortions are invented or exaggerated by some literature and mass
media. Obviously, the propaganda follows governmental policies
aimed at the birth rate elevation.
In societies with the rape myth acceptance, sexual violence is seen
as a method of acquiring wives [42,43]. The fact that some victims
married their rapists was erroneously seen as indication that women
enjoy it; in fact, existing accounts demonstrate various degrees of
trauma [43]. In this connection, battered woman syndrome and
learned helplessness must be timely recognized [44,45]. The sexual
and reproductive coercion is not always realized as such by victims.
Intimidation and shame can prevent a woman from describing
certain acts as coercion [39,46]. The maltreatment of women is underreported
especially in less open societies. Some boys are taught sexual
coercion in their families: experience with relatives is not unusual
in certain traditional and chaotic milieus [47,48]. It was estimated
that 49% of the “child perpetrators” had been sexually abused prior
to their own abusive behaviors [49]. Studies indicate a link between
child maltreatment including incest and sexual crime committed
by victims in their later life [49,50]. Males imprisoned for sexual
molesting had often been molested themselves in their childhood. A
similar paradigm has been suggested for intergenerational incest [48].
Various methods are used by perpetrators: seduction and persuasion
up to hypnosis, alcohol and drugs, intimidation and violence,
reproductive coercion and contraceptive sabotage, marriage fraud
and deceit including concealment of genetic diseases.
Cases are known when a hereditary disease was concealed from
the partner and then acquired by offspring [33]. Approximately
20-25% of Ashkenazi Jewscarry a mutation for a genetic disorder
[51,53]. Among others, prevalence of the following conditions
is above-average: Tay-Sachs disease, Alport, Lynch, Wolfram
syndromes, Glanzmann thrombasthenia, adrenal hyperplasia,
thromboangiitis obliterans, torsion dystonia, osteoporosis, cystic
fibrosis, mucolipidosis IV, pentosuria, diabetes, polycythemia vera,
some solid cancers and leukemias, certain ophthalmic and other
disorders [5-611], as well as predisposition to neurasthenia
[62].Some conditions are comparatively very frequent; for example,
familial dysautonomia occurs almost exclusively in the above-named
population; Bloom syndrome is ~600 times more prevalent than in the
background. Approximately one in 10-15 Ashkenazi individuals are
carriers of a mutation causing type 1 Gaucher disease, 1/30 –familial
dysautonomia,1/75 – A or B type of Niemann-Pick disease;1/40 are
estimated to be carriers for Canavan disease,1/89 - Fanconi anemia
and so forth[63]. Many mutations are not uniquely Jewish, being the
same as in the surrounding population [64,65]. Apparently, abnormal
genes tend to be gathered and accumulated. The mechanism can be
illustrated by a family case observed by the author. A professor, ethnic
Russian, having recognizable Marfan syndrome, married a young
and beautiful colleague of partly Jewish descent. Their daughter and
grandson both had the same syndrome, which complicated their
lives. The daughter migrated to Israel with her second husband who
concealed a hereditary disorder from his bride; she noticed only
polythelia, known to be associated with congenital malformations
[66].Their female offspring acquired Stein-Leventhal syndrome;
other relatives had ocular, intestinal diseases, severe allergy etc.
Screening of the Ashkenazi population for recessive disease-related
mutations is recommended [61,67,68]; one grandparent suffices to
offer a genetic examination [51]. The problematic heredity may give
rise to conscious or subconscious motives to look for partners from
different ethnic backgrounds [33]. A motivation for eugenics has been
a fear of hereditary degeneration [69]. There is a maxim: “Do not have
children unless you are sure that they will be healthy both mentally
and physically” [52]. This suggestion is not realizable in conditions
of sexual and reproductive coercion, contraceptive sabotage or
concealment of heritable conditions from partners. Reproductive
coercion is regarded to be a form of intimate partner violence; it can
lead to unintended pregnancy, abortions, poor pregnancy outcomes,
sexually transmitted infections, psychological trauma and depression
[70-73]. In the author’s opinion, contraceptive sabotage must be
qualified as crime with infliction of bodily harm if an abortion or
unwanted pregnancy, sexually transmitted or genetic disease has
been inflicted intentionally or by negligence.
Among others, the propensity for migrations and vagabondage
may be associated with certain genetic and/or ethnic characteristics.
In particular, migration may be desirable for people with
abnormalities because behavioral and other deviations are less
conspicuous abroad as the person is not typical just because he or
she comes from another country, due to the language barrier etc. In
a foreign environment, persons with abnormalities may be devoid
of stigma at least temporarily [74,75]. The grass is greener on the
other side of the fence not for everybody but for some individuals
for certain reasons. Among the causes may be inherited features and/
or affiliation with ethnic minorities. Another demographic problem,
the deepening gender imbalance due to sex-selective abortions and
female neonaticide, has been discussed elsewhere [25,33]. It should
be pointed out that the growing excess of males contributes to their
marginalization, antisocial behavior as well as to militarism and
international conflicts.
Conclusion
Birth control has been obfuscated by presumed national
interests; the demographic growth being supposed to strengthen
the sovereignty and defenses. Smoldering international conflicts
contribute to the population growth in certain regions. In the past,
the overpopulation was counteracted by wars, pestilence and famine.
Today, scientifically based humane methods can be used to regulate
the population size taking into account ecological and economical
realities in different regions. Large projects could be accomplished
to improve the quality of life: irrigation systems, nuclear and
other energy sources as an alternative to fossil fuels. Hydroelectric
power plants can be built on large rivers to produce hydrogen as
nonpolluting energy carrier. New substances used in the industry,
nutrition and medicine must be tested in large animal populations
to achieve statistical significance and to register are outcomes. Such
projects would create many jobs, being a reasonable alternative to
excessive military spendings. Not only durable peace but also mutual
trust is required for that. Unfortunately, trust may be abused. Some
confidence building measures have been applied and planned recently
[76,77]. An authority based in developed countries could counteract
the growing overpopulation and environmental damage.
Conflicts of interest:
The author has no conflicts of interest to declareReferences
3. Russell C, Russell WM (2000) Population crises and population cycles. Med Confl Surviv 16: 383-410.
23. Quandt WB (1988) The Middle East Ten years after Camp David. Washington DC: Brookings Institution.