Journal of Veterinary Science & Medicine
Download PDF
2. the percentage of medicines prescribed in generic name was calculated by dividing the number of medicines prescribed in generic name by the total number of prescribed medicines and multiplying by 100 to measure the propensity to prescribe in generic name;
Review Article
Review on Rational Use of Veterinary Drugs and Its Status in Ethiopia
Yitbarek T*
Sekota Dry Land Agricultural Research Center, P.o.box, 62 Sekota, Ethiopia
*Address for correspondence: Teklu Yitbarek, Sekota Dry Land Agricultural Research Center,
P.o.box, 62 Sekota, Ethiopia E-mail Id: tekluyitbarek2008@gmail.com
Submission:05 December, 2023
Accepted:01 February, 2024
Published:09 February 2024
Copyright: © 2024 Yitbarek T. This is an open-access article distributed
under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium provided the original work is properly cited.
Keywords
Veterinary Drug; Rational Use; Irrational Use; Ethiopia
Abstract
Over the past 100 years, medical care for animal diseases has evolved
significantly. The purpose of this paper is to review the rational use of veterinary
medicines and their current status in Ethiopia. Veterinary drugs are used
rationally or irrationally in the livestock sector for therapeutic, prophylactic,
and growth-promoting drugs, food preservation and processing, stress control
in slaughterhouses prior to slaughter, and reproductive control. Rational use
of drugs is the use of the right drug, in the right amount, at the right cost,
and at the right time. Irrational use of veterinary drugs is a major problem
when used in food-producing animals. Reasons for irrational drug use include
poor communication between owners and professionals, inadequate training
and education of veterinary graduates, demands from owners, and lack of
diagnostic equipment. Irrational use of drugs can negatively impact public
health, including: decreased quality of drug therapy leading to increased
mortality and morbidity; increased risk of undesirable effects (emergence of
drug resistance and side effects); waste of resources leading to decreased
availability of other important drugs; increased costs; adverse, sometimes
increased, in some cases lethal, effects, and so on. To promote the rational
use of drugs, WHO has announced 12 core interventions. In Ethiopian
veterinary clinics, there were problems with correct diagnosis, low prescriber
education levels, the presence of a small number of essential drugs, the
absence of a standard veterinary drug list, and inappropriate drug use leading
to irrational drug use. Therefore, attention should be paid to proper diagnosis,
educational status of prescribers, different types of drugs, and meeting all the
customs of the national veterinary drug lists and guidelines..
Introduction
Therapeutics for animal diseases has evolved significantly
over the past century. A wide variety of drugs are available, but
only a few are approved for use in animals for specific indications.
The relative paucity of veterinary medicines approved for a
wide variety of animal species results in veterinarians using
products outside of the approved conditions of use detailed in the
Summary of Product Characteristics to treat disease and relieve
suffering [1].
Veterinary drugs are used rationally or irrationally in the
livestock sector as cures, prophylactics, and growth promoters.
The concept of rational drug use is ancient, as evidenced by
the words of the Alexandrian physician Herophilus in 300 B.C.:
“Drugs are of no use in themselves, but are the very hand of God
when used with reason and prudence. Rational drug use has
taken on greater significance today from medical, socioeconomic,
and legal aspects [2].
Rational use of drugs is the use of the right drug, in the right
dosage, at the right cost, and at the right time, as is often reflected
in the World Health Organization (WHO). On the other hand,
irrational use of drugs is defined as “too many prescriptions
per patient, injectable drugs being used when oral formulations
would be more appropriate, inappropriate antimicrobial
prescription quantities or regimens, antibiotics being prescribed
for nonbacterial infections, prescriptions not following clinical
guidelines, inappropriate self-treatment or not adhering to
prescribed therapy” [3]. Inappropriate use of drugs can lead to
ineffective treatment, unnecessary waste of resources, and harm
to patients [4].
The irrational use of drugs in veterinary medicine and
the need to control their use is an even greater problem when
they are used in food animals. In this case, trace amounts of the
drug or its metabolites remaining in edible tissues and animal
products (meat, milk, eggs, honey) can cause certain harmful
effects on humans, the potential consumers of such foods [5]. To
prevent this risk, drugs should be used rationally, i.e., only when
truly indicated, in the right way, at the right time, in the right
dose, and with a withdrawal period. In addition, sensitivity to
antimicrobial agents should be regularly controlled and residues
of antimicrobial agents commonly used in veterinary practice
should be regulated [6].
Ethiopia is a treasure trove of livestock and is considered
to have the largest number of livestock in Africa. The Central
Bureau of Statistics reports that there are approximately 60.39
million head of cattle, 31.3 million sheep, 32.74 million goats,
56.06 million poultry, 2.01 million horses, 8.85 million donkeys,
460,000 mules, and 1.42 million camels in the settled areas of
the country [7]. However, despite this huge livestock population,
Ethiopia is not utilizing its livestock resources as expected due
to a number of factors, including livestock diseases, recurrent
droughts, infrastructure problems, the spread of livestock
diseases, poor nutrition, improper husbandry practices, lack of
trained personnel, and government policies regarding disease
prevention and control [8]. Widespread livestock diseases are a
major constraint to livestock development in Ethiopia [9],and as
a result, veterinarians use anthelmintics and antibiotics to treat
these diseases.
In Ethiopia, studies conducted on humans in hospitals
in different regions of the country revealed the presence of
irrational drug use [10] Similarly, in veterinary medicine, studies
reported in central Ethiopia [11-13] showed the presence of
irrational use of veterinary drugs in veterinary clinics in Bishoft,
Adama District and Mojo, respectively.
Therefore, the purpose of this paper was:
➢ To review the rational use of veterinary drugs.
➢ To show the use of veterinary drugs in Ethiopia.
Literature Review
Uses of Veterinary Drugs:
Veterinary medicines play an important role in livestock
production and are generally used in livestock for therapeutic
and preventive purposes, growth promotion, feed preservation
and processing, and stress control before slaughter, and can be
administered in feed or in drinking water [14]. Prophylactic use
refers to the use of a drug by an individual or group to prevent the
onset of an infectious disease, while therapeutic use refers to the
treatment of an established infectious disease. Both prophylactic
and therapeutic use involve short-term administration of
therapeutic levels of drugs through different routes [15]. The use
of antimicrobials as feed supplements can promote growth and
increase feed efficiency in food animals [16].Antimicrobial agents are compounds that kill pathogenic
microorganisms in the animal body without adversely affecting
the host. Antimicrobials are natural products of various species
of bacteria and fungi that cause the death (bactericidal effect) or
growth inhibition (bacterio static effect) of microorganisms at
low concentrations [17].
Therapeutic and prophylactic use: The use of antimicrobials
in healthy animals considered to be at risk of infection or before
the onset of clinical infection implies disease-preventive use
(prophylactic use) of antimicrobials. This includes the prevention
of infections that have not yet been clinically diagnosed or their
use to control the spread of clinically diagnosed infections
identified in a group of animals. The use of antimicrobials for
the specific purpose of treating animals with clinically diagnosed
infections or diseases is referred to as therapeutic use of
antimicrobials [18].
Therapeutic and prophylactic drugs, divided into different
groups according to their action, such as antiparasitic,
antibacterial, and antifungal drugs, are the most widely
distributed drugs and are used to treat and prevent animal
diseases [19].
Growth promoters: A growth promoter is any antimicrobial
agent that is administered in low doses below the therapeutic
dose and destroys or inhabits the growth of microorganisms that
reduce animal food yield as infectious pathogens [20]. Antibiotic
growth promoters are used to aid animal growth by reversing the
percentage of weight again to improve feed saving efficiency [16].
A variety of compounds with growth-promoting properties can be found in various veterinary drugs. Typical examples are β-adrenergic agonists, which are intended to increase growth efficiency and meat percentage in the carcass, especially by promoting protein synthesis and reducing fat content. Antithyroid agents and corticosteroids can be applied alone to increase food intake, weight gain, fat content and water retention, or in combination with β-agonists to increase water content in meat, or with anabolic steroids [21].
A variety of compounds with growth-promoting properties can be found in various veterinary drugs. Typical examples are β-adrenergic agonists, which are intended to increase growth efficiency and meat percentage in the carcass, especially by promoting protein synthesis and reducing fat content. Antithyroid agents and corticosteroids can be applied alone to increase food intake, weight gain, fat content and water retention, or in combination with β-agonists to increase water content in meat, or with anabolic steroids [21].
Preservation and processing of food: A preservative is a substance that can inhibit, delay, or prevent the growth of
microorganisms or other deterioration caused by their presence.
Food preservatives extend the shelf life of certain foods.
Preservatives slow microbial deterioration and thus preserve
the color, texture, and flavor of foods. Food preservatives can
be classified as natural or artificial. Artificial preservatives are
produced industrially. They are classified as antimicrobial,
antioxidant, and anti-enzyme agents [22].
Food additives are added in food preservation and processing
to prevent spoilage, promote binding, and enhance flavor and
nutritional value. These additives include sequestering agents,
antioxidants, stabilizers, colorants, softeners, and sweeteners.
Residues and contaminants can enter the food chain through
intentional exposure to these chemicals during both the
production and processing stages [23].
Pre slaughter control of stress in abattoir: Transportation of animals to slaughterhouses is a process that involves exposing
animals to many stressful stimuli, including environmental,
psychological, and physiological factors. A common practice
in the meat production industry is to use medical procedures
to prevent stress, avoid market penalties (i.e., low demand low
price) for poor quality meat that may be directly attributable to
transportation to slaughterhouses, and minimize economic losses
due to the health of animals prone to stressful conditions It is to
minimize the economic losses due to stressful animal health [24].
In the past, treatments involving tranquilizers were often
used to reduce stress in animals. However, the use of such
tranquilizers has been banned in the EU due to the risk of
residues in meat, and there is an urgent need to find new ways to
calm animals during transport. One possible solution is the use of
a legally approved additive. This additive can be administered by
mixing it into the animal’s food or drinking water, and its effects
on stress reduction and meat quality are well known. Currently,
the selection and application of drugs (agonists, antagonists,
dopaminergic agonists, benzodiazepine opiates, barbiturates)
and dietary supplements (magnesium, vitamins, amino acids) as
anti-stress agents is empirical and scientific justification in terms
of stress neurochemistry is usually not available [24].
Control of reproduction: Prostaglandins are reproductive hormones used to manipulate reproduction in cattle. Its two
main uses in the export trade of live cattle are to terminate
unwanted pregnancies and to synchronize estrus prior to
artificial insemination of breeding cows. Unwanted pregnancies
can be terminated by administering prostaglandins 7 to 150
days after conception. Administration of prostaglandins between
7 and 100 days after conception will reliably induce abortion
after 3 to 5 days with relatively few complications. Estrus
synchronization is always performed under the guidance of an AI
center or veterinarian familiar with cattle reproduction and has
few problems as long as the cows are healthy and not pregnant
[22].
Sex steroids, prostaglandins and their analogues are used
to regulate reproductive and fertility programs. Prostaglandins
and glucocorticoids are used to control the timing of calving
and as abortifacients. Shortly after treatment, animals are not
slaughtered, and residue problems in meat can occur only in
cases of causal slaughter [23].
Ways of Veterinary Drug Use:
Rational veterinary drug use:Rational use of veterinary
medicines means that sick animals receive the appropriate
amount of medicine for their clinical needs, for the appropriate
duration, and at the least cost [23]This requirement is met if the prescribing process is properly
followed. This includes defining safe and effective treatments
(non-drug and drug), procedures for defining (diagnosing) the
patient’s problem, writing the prescription, providing appropriate
information to the patient, selecting appropriate drugs, regimens,
and doses, and planning for evaluation of treatment efficacy [23].
Promoting rational drug use requires a wide range of
activities, including adaptation of the essential drug concept,
ongoing training of health professionals, and development of
evidence-based clinical guidelines. Unbiased and independent
drug information, consumer education, and regulatory strategies
are also essential to promote rational drug use [3].
Irrational veterinary drug use:Unreasonable use of a drug
means misuse of the drug by the patient (i.e., administration of a
drug inappropriate to the patient’s clinical needs, under- or overdosing
that is not commensurate with the patient’s individual
needs, inadequate duration of administration) [14] i.e., under
prescribing, overprescribing, incorrect prescribing, extravagant
prescribing, and multiple prescribing [25].
Under prescribing:
Indicates instances in which the dosage or duration of
treatment is inadequate or necessary drugs are not prescribed.
This is the case, for example, when the dosage is inadequate for
the patient’s weight [26]. However, there are also cases where a
physician decides not to prescribe a drug after due consideration,
which is considered reasonable underprescribing [27]. reported
that in 65% of patients, the prescribing physician decided
not to prescribe a particular drug after due consideration.
Underprescribing is a potential cause of significant morbidity
and mortality, but it remains a less noted issue in the field of drug
use [28].Overprescribing:This refers to cases in which a drug is
prescribed without an indication, or even if indicated, the
duration of treatment is too long, or the amount of drug given
to the patient exceeds what is necessary for the current course
of treatment. For example, this is the case when antibiotics are
given for days for a mild infection that can be treated for a few
days, or when antibiotics are initially prescribed when a viral
infection is suspected [29].
Inappropriate prescribing: this can occur when a medicine
is prescribed because of an incorrect diagnosis or when the
prescription is not properly written or does not take into account
the genetic, medical or environmental characteristics of the
patient [28]. For example, when a physician fails to take into
account if a patient has allergies that may be triggered by the
newly prescribed medication. It is also considered inappropriate
prescribing if the physician does not take into account that
prescribing a particular drug may react with the patient’s current
treatment (e.g., prescribing a serotonergic antidepressant to a
patient who is already taking a monoamine oxidase inhibitor)
[30].
Extravagant prescribing: presumably occurs when doctors
prescribe more expensive drugs despite the availability of
cheaper drugs with comparable safety and efficacy, or when
doctors treat patients symptomatically rather than addressing
the underlying serious condition. For example, prescribing
unnecessarily expensive cough medicines has provided little
benefit compared to commonly available less expensive options.
Similarly, extravagant prescribing is said to occur when a class
of patented drugs is prescribed even though there are cheaper
generic alternatives in the same class that can be used without
compromising treatment. Such classes include renin angiotensin
angiotensin inhibitors, proton pump inhibitors and statins [31].
Multiple prescribing: when two or more medicines are
prescribed and fewer than one of them will have the same effect,
or when the prescriber is treating several related diseases, even
if the treatment of the underlying (primary) disease may cure or
treat other diseases [25].
The irrational use of drugs is of particular concern due to the
development of resistant bacteria. The abuse and heavy use of
antimicrobials has made them a serious problem in both human
and veterinary medicine [32]. Widespread misuse of authorized
drugs has led to the discovery of undesirable residues in food of
animal origin. Non-compliance with recommended withdrawal
and retention times for antimicrobials is also widespread [33].
Unnecessary medicines may be prescribed, such as high
doses of multivitamins to patients without nutritional problems
or antibiotics to patients without evidence of bacterial disease.
For the use of medicines to be reasonable, they must be effective,
safe, prescribed for the right therapeutic indication, in the
right dosage, in the right formulation, easily available and at a
reasonable cost [34].
Significance of Rational Veterinary Drug Use:
Rational use of drugs in veterinary medicine is of important
public health and economic importance. and economic
significances.Public health significance: When veterinary medicinal
products are used at appropriate doses and levels, adverse
human health effects occurring in food have not been reported
[35].
Improve food safety concern: When veterinary drugs are used rationally, the potential adverse effects of animal
consumption of food products are small. However, when
veterinary drugs are used irrationally, mainly in food animals,
very small amounts of the drug or its metabolites (residues) in
products of animal origin (meat, milk, eggs, honey) can cause
specific adverse effects in humans, potential consumers of such
products [6].
Reduce the development of drug resistance: The very high incidence of resistance to antimicrobials used for treatment and
growth promotion in food animal husbandry has been observed
in several studies. However, most reports are based on survey
studies and are severely hampered by the lack of appropriate
epidemiological selection criteria and reliance on pathogens
isolated from clinically pathological and possibly dosed animals.
Information on resistance outbreaks at local, regional or
international level is needed to guide policies and detect changes
that require response strategies. To meet this requirement,
a system for continuous monitoring of changes in resistance
epidemics is needed [36].
Resistant microorganisms are transmitted to humans either
by direct contact or indirectly through milk, meat or eggs.
Contamination of food of animal origin with bacteria from the
endogenous flora of food-producing animals can lead to human
infection, transfer of resistance genes to the human endogenous
flora, or a new load on the reservoir of resistance genes already
present in humans [37].
In addition, the rational use of medicines can significantly
minimize the risk of microorganisms acquiring resistance (in the
case of antimicrobials). Therefore, when veterinary medicines
are used at appropriate doses and levels, a significant proportion
of adverse human health effects occurring in food have not been
reported [35].
Reduce the development of drug residue: Humans consume protein-rich foods, mostly of animal origin, to meet their
nutritional requirements. In some countries, the safety of foods
of animal origin has focused on preventing the transmission of
zoonotic diseases, while less attention has been paid to potentially
present chemical residues [21]. Today, growing consumer
awareness of the increasing chemicalization of foods of animal
origin (meat, milk, eggs and their products) is a challenge facing
the dairy, meat and poultry industries. Many chemicals are used
directly or indirectly in the production, processing and storage
of animal products. On the other hand, environmental pollution
due to increasing urbanization and industrialization, as well as
the inappropriate use of veterinary drugs, can also lead to the
presence of residues in food [38].
Chemical contaminants are potentially harmful chemicals
of human or natural origin that can be present in food through
intentional handling or accidental contamination during food
production, processing and storage. Contamination of food by
pathogenic microorganisms and residual chemicals can occur
during production, transportation, storage, distribution and
preparation for consumption at the farm level [11].
Foods of animal origin can be contaminated with one or
more of the thousands of manufactured chemicals used in the
community. Relatively few chemicals are regularly found in
animal foods and the most problematic residues (in terms of
likelihood of occurrence and impact on human health, trade
and consumer confidence) are antimicrobial agents, hormone
growth promoters and production aids, polyhalogenated
hydrocarbon pesticides, industrial chemicals and heavy metals
38. Some of the manufactured chemicals in food are additives
used intentionally for production, processing and preservation.
Some of these, e.g. nitrites, are of concern as toxic metabolites
(e.g. nitrosamines) can form in food before ingestion. Chemical
residues (e.g. iodine, chlorine, bromine) are also contaminants
due to hygiene procedures and some are occasionally transferred
from packaging materials [11].
One of the most important problems of food contamination is
veterinary drug residues. Human health can be affected by drug
residues in foods of animal origin and can cause direct adverse
effects. In general, the consequences of antibiotic residues in
foods of animal origin are significant compared to the misuse
of antibiotics and the selection and proliferation of antibioticresistant
bacteria [20]. Foods of animal origin, such as meat, milk
and eggs, may have residues of veterinary drugs in edible tissues
after harvest. In some countries where farmers/producers
comply with legal directives, residue levels of veterinary drugs
are within safe limits. However, in a relatively small number of
cases, residue levels exceed the maximum permitted limits. This
is due to inappropriate/irrational drug use and is therefore not
legally permitted in the food system [39].
Economic significance: A wide spread availability and use of
antimicrobials have several negative implications on global health
care; development of drug resistance is one of among these. The
primary economic implications of resistance on the diminishing
efficacy of antibiotic treatment includes the need to rely on
more expensive drugs that may be practically unaffordable for
most primary health care programs [19]. From the prospective
of international trade and consumer confidence antimicrobial
residue remains very significant, because it results barrier of
international trade. As tariffs are removed and goods flow freely
between countries, importing countries must be in confident
that goods available for purchase are safe, and in addition to this,
from time to time, there is pressure to use antimicrobial residues
on non-tariffs barrier to importation. Major economic loses and
animal welfare problems could arise in veterinary medicine,
because antimicrobial resistance has been found to cause therapy
failure and higher morbidity and mortality rate [15].
Reason for Irrational Use of Drugs:
There are several reasons for irrational drug use. These
include poor communication between animal owners and
professionals, lack of information, inadequate education and
training of medical and veterinary graduates, demands of animal
owners (clinicians prescribe drugs for every complaint to meet
patients’ expectations and demands for early relief) and lack of
diagnostic facilities/uncertainty of diagnosis. There is also the
idea that ‘there is a drug for every disease’. All this increases
the tendency towards polypharmacy, imperfect drug supply
systems, promotional activities of pharmaceutical companies
and ineffective drug regulation (the absence of a well-organized
drug regulatory authority and the large number of drugs on the
market leads to irrational use of drugs) [40].Lack of information: Unlike in developed countries, there is no
regular facility to provide up-to-date and unbiased information on
currently used medicines. The majority of general practitioners
rely on health professionals for information on medicines. There
are differences between pharmaceutical companies and drug
regulatory authorities in the interpretation of data on the efficacy
and safety of medicines [41].
Inadequate training and education in medical injections and
cough and cold medications: injections have graduated: lack of
adequate clinical training in writing proper prescriptions during
the training period and increasing over-reliance on diagnostic
aids rather than improving clinical diagnostic skills [40].
Poor communication between health workers and patients:
health workers and other health professionals spend too little
time with patients and do not explain basic information about the
use of medicines, do not give prescriptions to patients and stop
talking to them [42].
Lack of diagnostic facilities/uncertainty of diagnosis:
Accurate diagnosis is an important step for rational medical
care. Doctors working in remote areas face many difficulties in
reaching the correct diagnosis due to lack of diagnostic facilities.
This encourages polypharmacy [41].
Patient demand: To meet patients’ expectations and satisfy
their demand for quick relief, clinicians prescribe medication
for all complaints and provide symptomatic treatment. There is
also the belief that ‘for every disease there is a cure’. These have
increased the trend towards polypharmacy [42].
Flawed drug supply systems and ineffective drug regulation:
the absence of a well-organized drug regulatory authority leads
to irrational use of medicines [42].
Drug promotion: lucrative promotional programs of various
pharmaceutical industries influence drug prescribing [41].
Consequences of Irrational Use of Drugs:
Irrational use of medicines can have negative public health
consequences, including reduced quality of drug therapy
leading to increased mortality and morbidity (limited efficacy)
and increased risk of adverse effects such as the emergence of
drug resistance due to widespread overuse of antibiotics, use of
lower than therapeutic doses, increased side effects and waste
of resources, leading to reduced availability of other important
medicines, increased costs and adverse, possibly fatal, effects
[40-43].A study in one region in India found that 69.2 percent of
pharmaceutical expenditure is wasted in the private sector
and 55.4 percent in the public sector. In this region, 14.76
billion rupees were wasted on irrational prescribing in a
single year, accounting for 67.58 percent of the region’s total
drug consumption. Irrational prescribing also has a negative
psychosocial impact, as it perpetuates the notion that ‘every
condition needs a medicine’ [43].
The overuse of antimicrobials and anthelminthic in veterinary
practice contributes to the development of intrinsic or acquired
antimicrobial and anthelminthic resistance in both food and
companion animals. Acquired resistance develops as a result of
intensive and irrational use of drugs, while intrinsic resistance
is the result of natural structural or functional traits that
confer resistance to a particular drug or class of antimicrobials.
Antimicrobial/anthelminthic resistance is a growing problem and
indeed the development of new drugs may not be the solution.
Common causes of antimicrobial resistance include unnecessary
use of antimicrobials, inappropriate dosage, inadequate duration
of treatment and irrational use of antimicrobial combinations
[11].
Side effects, including misuse of antimicrobials, which can
be fatal; limited efficacy of antimicrobials, TB drugs and leprosy
drugs, e.g. due to inadequate therapeutic doses; antimicrobial
resistance due to overuse or inadequate therapeutic doses
of antimicrobials; drug dependence, e.g. through routine
use of analgesics and tranquilizers; risk of infection through
inappropriate use of injections, e.g. injection abscesses Waste
of resources; reduced availability of other important medicines,
increased costs. Risk of infection through inappropriate use
of injections (such as injection abscesses); waste of resources;
reduced availability of other important medicines; increased
costs [40].
Measures to Promote Rational Veterinary Drug Use:
The importance of promoting the rational use of medicines
is evident from the fact that various initiatives in this direction
have been incorporated into health systems at both national
and international level. In addition to a wealth of information,
educational resources for medicines and therapeutic committees
are available in downloadable format from the website. For
example, WHO publications such as the Good Prescribing
Guidelines are easily downloadable [43]Keep all food animals in as clean and healthy an environment
as possible. Feeding programs should meet the needs of lactation,
growth and maintenance periods. Health programs, including
preventive medical procedures, should be carried out by
veterinarians. Unnecessary and incorrect use of medicines is best
prevented by implementing health programs and management
practices that keep animals healthy and enable them to produce
efficiently [15].
There are several strategies to minimize the misuse of
antimicrobials. These include: education to raise awareness
among farmers; training of prescribers and dispensers
(including drug sellers); ensuring that only antimicrobials that
meet international standards for quality, safety and efficacy are
allowed for sale; establishing and maintaining up-to-date national
standard treatment guidelines; limiting access to antimicrobials
by prescription; reducing the need for antimicrobials by
developing guidelines for veterinarians and strengthening
immunization coverage and other preventive measures to reduce
misuse and overuse of antimicrobials in food-producing animals
[15].
Failure to adhere to recommended withdrawal periods
often leads to residue problems and it is therefore advisable to
adhere to recommended withdrawal periods to avoid residual
effects of medicines on animal food. This means that prescribed
withdrawal periods for specific medicines should be established
and adhered to, and food animals should not be sold for slaughter
or slaughtered before the withdrawal period has expired [14].
To promote more rational use of medicines, WHO has
published 12 key interventions. These include clinical guidelines,
public education on medicines, appropriate and mandatory
regulations, independent information on medicines, surveillance,
audit and feedback, and problem-based drug therapy education
in undergraduate curricula [44].
Prescribing Indicators:
There are no existing guidelines on prescribing indicators
used in veterinary medicine. As a result, the WHO prescribing
indicators presented below were considered most appropriate
as prescribing indicators for use in veterinary research. This
indicator has been pre-tested and slightly modified to be
consistent with clinical practice in veterinary medicine so that it
can be used to provide accurate data [45].The final versions of the pretested indicators are::
1. To measure the extent of polypharmacy, the total number
of different medicines prescribed was divided by the number
of cases studied to calculate the average number of medicines
prescribed per case. The combination of medicines prescribed
for a health problem was fixed and counted as one;2. the percentage of medicines prescribed in generic name was calculated by dividing the number of medicines prescribed in generic name by the total number of prescribed medicines and multiplying by 100 to measure the propensity to prescribe in generic name;
3. The proportion of consultations where antimicrobials,
anthelmintics and other medicines were prescribed was
calculated by dividing the number of consultations where
medicines were prescribed by the total number of consultations
reviewed and multiplying by 100 to measure the overall use
of overused (unreasonably prescribed) and expensive drug
therapies.
4. The proportion of drugs prescribed from the Ethiopian National Veterinary Drug List (EVDL) was calculated as the total number of drugs prescribed divided by the total number of prescribed items on the veterinary drug list to measure the extent to which the practice complies with the national drug policy as described in the Ethiopian EVDL and divided by the number of prescribed items and multiplied by 100 [46].
4. The proportion of drugs prescribed from the Ethiopian National Veterinary Drug List (EVDL) was calculated as the total number of drugs prescribed divided by the total number of prescribed items on the veterinary drug list to measure the extent to which the practice complies with the national drug policy as described in the Ethiopian EVDL and divided by the number of prescribed items and multiplied by 100 [46].
5. The rational use of veterinary medicines means that sick
animals receive the medication appropriate to their clinical
needs, for the appropriate duration, in the dose that meets
appropriate individual requirements and at the lowest cost to
the patient and society [23]. Irrational drug use, on the other
hand, means that patients misuse drugs (i.e. patients are given
too much or in doses that are not appropriate for their clinical
needs, for the appropriate duration, in doses that do not meet
appropriate individual requirements) [47].
Veterinary drug use patterns/status in Ethiopia:
Several studies on the rational use of veterinary drugs in
Ethiopia have shown that irrational drug use is very common in
the study area: In a study by [12], antimicrobials were irrationally
prescribed for viral diseases (16.2%) and surgical cases (5.6%),
anthelmintics were also irrationally prescribed for bacterial
diseases (2.9%) and surgical cases (0.9%); In a study by [13],
anthelmintics were irrationally prescribed for bacterial (28.7%),
metabolic (7%) and viral (3.8%) diseases and antimicrobials
were irrationally prescribed for viral (26.2%), parasitic (8.6%),
surgical (0.2%) and metabolic diseases (0.9%). [48] also reported
that anthelmintics were prescribed for 44.3% of non-parasitic
diseases at Gondar University Veterinary clinics.The route of administration was not specified in 96.5%
[13],99.1% [12] and 98.9% [11] of prescribed medications,
contributing to the presence of irrational drug use.
A study on the educational status of prescribers showed that
the majority of prescribers at Mojo Veterinary Hospital were
animal health assistants (67.9%) or at diploma level, while only
32.06% were veterinary surgeons. This study is in line with
similar studies conducted at Adama VeterinaryClinic 88.1%
and 11.9% [12], VTH-CVMA and Ada District Veterinary Clinic
where 70.8% and 29.2% [11]of prescriptions were written by
animal health assistants and veterinary surgeons respectively.
This suggests that the level of education of those prescribing
veterinary medicines is low and care needs to be taken to avoid
treatment errors, misuse of medicines and development of drug
resistance.
Ethiopia’s Federal Constitutional Decree No. 728-2011
stipulates that veterinary medicines should only be prescribed
by veterinarians. It also states that veterinarians must follow
prescribing procedures and prescribe veterinary drugs on
standard prescription forms [49]. 98.2% of patients admitted
to Mojo Veterinary Clinic [13], CVMA-VTH and Adama District
Veterinary Clinic [11] and 96.6% of patients admitted to Adama
District Veterinary Clinic [12] received empirical treatment
and did not receive a correct definitive diagnosis (laboratory
support). This suggests that affected animals were treated only
on the basis of a provisional diagnosis. This suggests that affected
animals were not managed with specific treatment or that drugs
were used irrationally without knowing the specific cause of the
disease.
Conclusion
The review of this paper reveals the rational use of veterinary
drugs in Ethiopia and its pattern/situation. Veterinary medicines
are used rationally or irrationally in the livestock sector. Rational
use of medicines is the use of the right medicine, in the right
quantity, at the right cost and at the right time. Irrational drug
use can have negative effects on public health: reduced quality
of drug treatment leading to increased mortality and morbidity;
increased risk of adverse effects such as drug resistance and
the emergence of side effects; wastage of resources making
other important medicines unavailable; increased costs and, in
some cases, fatal side effects, among others. Studies in Ethiopia
have shown that accurate diagnosis of disease and selection of
appropriate drugs is problematic; lack of laboratory tests, low
education levels of prescribers, availability of few essential
drugs, lack of a national veterinary drug list and standard
veterinary drug treatment guidelines, standard prescription
forms, standard case forms and case registers are of high public
health importance and lead to irrational drug use. Therefore,
correct diagnosis and appropriate diagnosis selection practices
should be carried out, clinical examination, educational status
of prescribers, different types of drugs, national veterinary
drug lists and guidelines, standard prescription forms and case
records, and all issues related to these that lead to irrational
drug use should be met and paid attention to. What to pay
attention to. Appropriate medicines should be prescribed in
appropriate doses, routes and regimens. Laboratory support
for confirmation of provisionally diagnosed diseases should be
provided and laboratory equipment, chemicals and reagents
should be enriched. Governments, private veterinary practices,
private veterinarians and animal owners should promote the
rational use of medicines. Veterinarians should be made aware
of the irrational use of veterinary medicines and their impact on
public health.
Conflicts of Interest:
The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest
regarding the publication of this article.Authors’ Contributions:
TekluYitbarek was responsible for all things related to this
review.Acknowledgments
I would like to thank the Almightily GOD for giving me
strength to do this review.